Guest Stars Emily Marie Palmer as Sister Isabella Chris Wood as Captain Lance Van Der Berg Nyambi Nyambi as Caleb Co Starring Luray Cooper as Abel Melcher Kate Forbes as Mrs. Olivia Fairfax Tiffany Green as Elizabeth Tim Powell as Mutt Murphy Brannon Cross as Agent Cahill Jon Stafford as Older Patient Sasha Morfaw as Contraband Singer Sam Malone as Quincy Bobby Daniels as Old Man Vonii Bristow as Isaac Peter Laprade as Typhoid Patient Jeremy Wood as Drunken Soldier #2 Gabe Wood as Union Prison Guard David Foster as Lincoln Tanner Martinelli as Drunken Soldier #1 Christopher Speed as Bee-Stung Soldier Justin Smith as Charlotte's Carriage Driver Jamie Renell as Knight