Guest Stars Toby Huss as Big Mike Wanru Tseng as Cindy Kyle Dunnigan as Craig Pullin Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Jessie Camacho as Chupi Chupi Gene LeBell as Grandpa Aziz Ansari as Resort Salesman #3 Paul Scheer as Resort Salesman #1 Rob Huebel as Resort Salesman #2 Jay Johnston as FBI Agent Carrie Wiita as High School Principal Michael Lopez as Sponge Imposter Robert Covarrubias as Ice Cream Party Dad Bob Herron as Bob Herron Lisa Dempsey as Brakeless Passenger Gina Hieber as Brakeless Driver