Guest Stars Toby Huss as Big Mike Jim Rash as Andrew Kristina Hayes as Principal Manderville Nick Kroll as El Chupacabra Jessie Camacho as Chupi Chupi Matt Walsh as Ranger Glen Neil Campbell as Cap'n Crabby's Manager Julie Brister as Neighborhood Watch Lady Sandy Gimpel as Biker Bar Owner Alex Berg as New Deputy #2 Alex Fernie as New Deputy #1 Todd Fasen as New Deputy #3 Jason Zumwalt as George the Manager Tommy Rosales as Burglar