Guest Stars David Ogden Stiers as Reverend Eugene "Gene" Purdy Bill Mondy as Deputy Roscoe Kristen Dalton as Dana Bright Michael St. John Smith as Mike Kennedy Kirsten Prout as Susan Reed Alan C. Peterson as Bert aka Hefty Man Tom Butler as Judge Wilson Patrick Keating as Tom Reed Tim Henry as Sheriff Jim Danforth Scott Heindl as Eddie Wolcott Ben Ratner as Public Defender Gabriel Barnes Kate Robbins as Waitress Linda Kathryn Kirkpatrick as Deputy Nancy Simmons Jane Sowerby as Mary Reed Michael David Simms as Prosecutor Doug Martin Jacqueline Bennett as Cathy Reed