Guest Stars David Ogden Stiers as Reverend Eugene "Gene" Purdy Bill Mondy as Deputy Roscoe Kristen Dalton as Dana Bright Michael St. John Smith as Mike Kennedy Carlos Joe Costa as Motel Manager Alicia Coppola as Anita / Nicholas Erin Karpluk as Maddy Tracey Gold as Penny Barton Beatrice Zeilinger as Cheryl Connor Peter Nicholas as Daniel Connor Lucas Margetson as Young Nicholas Connor