Guest Stars Jason George as Keith Bennett Tom Amandes as Martin Posner Tom Cavanagh as Jeremy Stone Steve Harris as Jayson Turk Patrick Breen as A.D.A. Paul Sweren Meta Golding as Carly Turk Rowena King as Holly Rains Madison Mason as Judge Samuel Asquith Alan Rachins as Familiar Lawyer Michael Cavanaugh as D.A. Lowell Grayson Co Starring Justin Lieberman as Eli, Age 12 Travis T. Flory as James