New England couple Edwin and Lillian are obsessed with vintage, and that has brought them to Springfield, Massachusetts, which is known for its extensive vintage architecture. However, these old house enthusiasts don't exactly agree on what their dream home looks like: Edwin loves Colonials and Tudors, while Lillian swoons for Victorians. Edwin has his sights set on modern kitchens and bathrooms, but Lillian wants original fixtures and features. Will they find a perfect piece of vintage property they both can agree on? Or will one of them have to compromise before the hunt is over?