Guest Stars Trieste Kelly Dunn as Captain Taylor Mathison Clara Wong as Mary Fowler Geoffrey Blake as Oliver Weber Aaron Serotsky as Attorney Dworkin Daniel Raymont as Vince Stowman Co Starring Adinah Alexander as Judge Edith Rothstein Amy Holmes as CBS Reporter Andrew Ayala as Juror Frederick West Natasha A. Murray as Mock Foreman #2 Joseph John Moffa as Person #1 Kendall Lloyd as Jury Foreman George Bruno Jannone as Older Man Lynne Valley as Juror Juliette Lee Jack Halpin as Airline Exec Khamailei Angelil as Aide Heather Hill as Mirror Juror Alice Ricardo Alvarado as Mock Foreman #4 Thomas Benton as Judge Ferris Blain Sanchez as Juror Dave Lemanski Lisa Therese Darden as Juror Alice Helen Mendes as Martha Plemmons Mirror Michele Tauber as Juror Martha Plemmons Malin Barr as Tanya Bryant Todd Faulkner as Dave Reynolds Denise Bessette as Mock Foreman #3 Kyle Lemaire as Mirror George Lawrence Arancio as Juror Orville Maynard Daniel Morgan Shelley as Rogers William Henderson White as Mock Foreman #1