Guest Stars Mort Burke as Various Characters Maria Blasucci as Various Characters Craig Cackowski as Various Characters Bennie Arthur as Various Characters Amber Ruffin as Herself (Narrator) Kyle Kinane as Himself (Narrator) Crissle West as Herself (Narrator) Michael Cera as Andrew Jackson Brendan Sexton III as Thomas Benton Vanessa Bayer as Carrie Nation Alexandra Grey as Marsha P. Johnson Trace Lysette as Sylvia Rivera Zander Ayeroff as LGBT Teen Dwight Yoakam as Jesse Benton Mariah I. Wilson as Nation Fangirl Skyler Shelley as LGBT Teen