Guest Stars Patton Oswalt as Neil Kowalski Michael J. Willett as Lionel Trane Michael Hitchcock as Ted Mayo Matthew Del Negro as Nick Hurley Pamela Reed as Beverly Craine Seth Gabel as Zach Co Starring Devon Woods as Young Tara Clarinda Ross as Young Mimi Layla Wyoming as Young Charmaine Billy Jayne as Ed Lucy Butler as Doreen Mydas Ian Jensen as Tall Guy Hilary Barraford as Lori