Special Guest Stars Sharon Gless as Chris MacNeil Guest Stars Mouzam Makkar as Jessica Kirsten Fitzgerald as Maria Walters Francis Guinan as Brother Simon Tim Hopper as Superintendent Jaffey Ken Marks as Lester Rego Keira Naughton as Cherry Rego James Vincent Meredith as Detective Lawrence Michael Patrick Thornton as Dr. John Rexroth Chaon Cross as TBD Co Starring Torrey Hanson as Cardinal Guillot Melissa Russell as Tara Alan Metoskie as Red Minita Gandhi as Reporter Sophie Thatcher as Young Regan Greg Stuhr as Talk Show Host Shadana Patterson as Ceci Stamps Kenn E. Head as Chicago Sun Reporter Lane Anthony Flores as Chattering Man