Guest Stars Dean Winters as Tony Silvercreek Jeffrey DeMunn as Max Brodkin Keisha Zollar as Grace J. Smith-Cameron as Elaine Campbell Gillian Vigman as Janice Rebekah Brockman as Galt Nicholas Feitel as Nick Jr. Dave Shalansky as Brad Zimmer Hazel Anne Raymundo as Natalie Molly Lloyd as Ellen Nia Minott as Sophie Jessica Cherniak as Basketball Player