Guest Stars Jenna Stern as Elana Barth Delaney Williams as Counselor John Buchanan Jason Bowen as Detective Marcus Perry Sarah Wynter as Dr. Nicole Keller Daniel Cosgrove as Dr. Daniel Keller Aaron Sanders as Luke Keller Co Starring Lauren Noble as Carmen Benton Greene as Charles Franklin Salma Shaw as Jury Foreperson Patrick Boll as James Miller Gage Polchlopek as Ethan Miller Chantal Jean-Pierre as Regina Franklin Olivia Sargent as Alexandra Handley Donald Dash as Trey Franklin Diedre Madigan as Allison Avery Marc LeVasseur as Attorney Alan Schwartz Tim Pettolina as Male Patient Scott Mena as Courthouse Pedestrian Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration