Guest Stars John Doman as Carmine Falcone Anthony Carrigan as Victor Zsasz Cameron Monaghan as Jerome Valeska Ivana Miličević as Maria Kyle Paul Reubens as Elijah Van Dahl David Dastmalchian as Dwight Pollard P.J. Marshall as Cole Clemons Brian McManamon as Basil Jan Maxwell as Margaret Hearst Dave Quay as Tarquin Co Starring Kaipo Schwab as Gus Angel Rosa as Cop #1 Jeannine Kaspar as Penny Anthony Caso as Priest Forrest Weber as Staff Member