Guest Stars Marie Avgeropoulos as Kirstie Nelson James Pizzinato as Nate Sefton Aisha Hinds as Detective Rosalind Sakelik Ben Hollingsworth as Peter Grey Stacey Farber as E.J. Andrew Leeds as Marc Segal Yurij Kis as Gil Ingrid Torrance as Gale Chris Nowland as Jimmy Michael Q. Adams as Priest Daren A. Herbert as Zac