Season 1 - Episode Guide

Returning to the small town where her parents were murdered many years ago, Sarah Bennett is horrified when she finds herself at the center of a new series of murders that bear an eerily similarity to the murder of her parents.

After she receives a gruesome and cryptic package in the mail, Sarah investigates the recent murders with help from an unlikely ally, leading to the discovery of a long buried secret. Robin has a close call with the killer, and Sarah's grandmother unexpectedly arrives at the Bennett home.

Unpleasant truths haunt Robin, who faces steep financial penalties for Justin's crimes. Meanwhile, a shocking misdeed from Brenda's youth causes Sarah to believe that the police have arrested the wrong person for the recent murders.

Sarah believes the killer is using the seven deadly sins as part of their plan and is disappointed by the police chief's lack of responsiveness. Unfortunately Sarah's attempt to investigate the murders leads to misfortune.

Sarah blames herself when another disturbing murder occurs. Meanwhile, Alison has mixed reactions to Dylan's TV commentaries about the killings and makes a bold move to grab the spotlight for herself.

Sarah learns of some unsettling information about her past from Tom Winston, which leads her to believe she knows the next target of the Executioner. Elsewhere, Chief Vaughn takes great pains to conceal the truth about his own history.

Convinced that Sarah is the Executioner's final target, Tom Winston escapes from prison. Sarah discovers the truth about her relationship with Dylan.

The Executioner plans one last grand act of retribution, while Sarah is comforted by Cam after Dylan's dishonesty.