Main Characters Eli McCullough 20 main appearances Pete McCullough 20 main appearances Maria Garcia 20 main appearances Jeannie McCullough 20 main appearances Sally 20 main appearances Young Eli McCullough 20 main appearances Phineas McCullough 20 main appearances Niles 18 main appearances Prairie Flower 18 main appearances Toshaway 17 main appearances Charles McCullough 8 main appearances Young Ingrid 9 main appearances Garcia 10 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Bigfoot Wallace 1 guest appearances Party Kid 1 guest appearances Ranger Hiram Bates 1 guest appearances Law and Order / Horseman 1 guest appearances Party Kid 1 guest appearances Sedicioso 1 guest appearances Lourdes García 1 guest appearances Tiny Dove 1 guest appearances Thick Hair 1 guest appearances The Buffalo Hunter 1 guest appearances Lena 1 guest appearances Maggie Phelps 1 guest appearances Sheriff Graham 1 guest appearances Capitán 1 guest appearances Overseer 1 guest appearances Pawnbroker 1 guest appearances Fire Keeper 1 guest appearances Cal Brogan 1 guest appearances Pink Stewart 1 guest appearances Manuel 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 » ⇥