Recurring Guest Characters Johnny Weir 1 guest appearances Gabby Douglas 1 guest appearances Vivica A. Fox 1 guest appearances Matt McGorry 1 guest appearances Cheryl Hines 1 guest appearances Ayesha Curry 1 guest appearances Graham Elliot 1 guest appearances Karamo Brown 1 guest appearances Alyson Hannigan 1 guest appearances Roselyn Sánchez 1 guest appearances Rob Gronkowski 1 guest appearances Julian Edelman 1 guest appearances Susan Kelechi Watson 1 guest appearances Jamie-Lynn Sigler 1 guest appearances Jay Pharoah 1 guest appearances Jay Glazer 1 guest appearances Jennie Garth 1 guest appearances Hill Harper 1 guest appearances Mary Lynn Rajskub 1 guest appearances James Van Der Beek 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 » ⇥