Recurring Guest Characters Brady Smith 9 guest appearances Ross Mathews 5 guest appearances Ashley Williams 4 guest appearances Tim DeKay 4 guest appearances Tim Meadows 3 guest appearances Bill Bellamy 3 guest appearances Ethan Embry 3 guest appearances Bree Turner 3 guest appearances Naomi Priestley 3 guest appearances Missi Pyle 2 guest appearances Eric Close 2 guest appearances Nicole Sullivan 2 guest appearances Mark-Paul Gosselaar 2 guest appearances Catriona Gosselaar 2 guest appearances Jennifer Finnigan 2 guest appearances Seth Green 2 guest appearances Clare Grant 2 guest appearances Matthew Lillard 2 guest appearances Willie Garson 2 guest appearances Jason Priestley 2 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 » ⇥