Recurring Guest Characters Rey Mysterio 1 guest appearances The Miz 1 guest appearances Gayle King 1 guest appearances Johnny Knoxville 1 guest appearances Jeff Tremaine 1 guest appearances Sophia Bush Hughes 1 guest appearances Neil Patrick Harris 1 guest appearances David Burtka 1 guest appearances Nikki Glaser 1 guest appearances Bebe Rexha 1 guest appearances Tiffany Haddish 1 guest appearances Justin Simien 1 guest appearances Christina Ricci 1 guest appearances Melanie Lynskey 1 guest appearances Warren Kole 1 guest appearances Tawny Cypress 1 guest appearances Lauren Ambrose 1 guest appearances Sammi Hanratty 1 guest appearances Sophie Nélisse 1 guest appearances Courtney Eaton 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 » ⇥