Main Characters Ichabod Crane 62 main appearances Jennifer "Jenny" Mills 49 main appearances Grace Abigail "Abbie" Mills 49 main appearances Frank Irving 31 main appearances Katrina Crane 30 main appearances Henry Parrish 18 main appearances Joseph "Joe" Corbin 15 main appearances Pandora 18 main appearances Daniel Reynolds 13 main appearances Betsy Ross 13 main appearances Sophie Foster 8 main appearances Diana Thomas 13 main appearances Malcolm Dreyfuss 13 main appearances Jake Wells 12 main appearances Alex Norwood 12 main appearances Molly Thomas 11 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Restoration Worker #3 1 guest appearances The Gargoyle 1 guest appearances Krissy Kowalick 1 guest appearances Wealthy Wife 1 guest appearances Wealthy Husband 1 guest appearances FBI Agent 1 guest appearances Doug Franks 1 guest appearances Stagehand 1 guest appearances Connor Dunne 1 guest appearances Drummer 1 guest appearances Bassist 1 guest appearances Guitarist 1 guest appearances Young Corbin 1 guest appearances Young Nevins 1 guest appearances Sleepy Hollow Officer / Hammond 1 guest appearances Vincent Rota 1 guest appearances Gary Wells 1 guest appearances Webb 1 guest appearances Docent 1 guest appearances Priest 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 » ⇥