Main Characters Sarah Fier 1 main appearances Deena Johnson 3 main appearances Samantha Fraser 3 main appearances Josh Johnson 3 main appearances Kate Schmidt 2 main appearances Simon Kalivoda 2 main appearances Sheriff Nick Goode 3 main appearances Mary Lane 3 main appearances Ruby Lane 3 main appearances C. Berman 2 main appearances Martin 2 main appearances Ziggy Berman 2 main appearances Cindy Berman 2 main appearances Alice 1 main appearances Tommy Slater 2 main appearances Young Nick Goode 1 main appearances Heather 1 main appearances Sheila 1 main appearances Solomon Goode 1 main appearances Constance 1 main appearances Hannah Miller 1 main appearances Henry Fier 1 main appearances Abigail 1 main appearances Mad Thomas 1 main appearances Lizzie 1 main appearances Isaac 1 main appearances The Widow 1 main appearances
Recurring Guest Characters Sarah Fier 3 guest appearances Kate Schmidt 1 guest appearances Simon Kalivoda 1 guest appearances Mayor Will Goode 3 guest appearances "The Milkman" Harry Rooker 3 guest appearances Billy Barker 3 guest appearances "Shame Killer" Isaac Milton 3 guest appearances "The Pastor" Cyrus Miller 3 guest appearances C. Berman 1 guest appearances Rachel Thompson / Sunnyvale Customer 2 guest appearances Skull Mask 2 guest appearances Peter 2 guest appearances Officer Kapinski 2 guest appearances Nightwing Killer 2 guest appearances Mrs. Fraser 2 guest appearances Alice 1 guest appearances Young Nick Goode 1 guest appearances TV Anchor 2 guest appearances Ryan Torres 1 guest appearances TV Reporter #1 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 » ⇥