Recurring Guest Characters Orchestra Leader 101 guest appearances Peggy King 95 guest appearances Jeff Donnell 70 guest appearances Fred MacMurray 9 guest appearances Tennessee Ernie Ford 7 guest appearances Eddie Fisher 6 guest appearances Anita Bryant 4 guest appearances Erin O'Brien 4 guest appearances Joe Flynn 4 guest appearances Imogene Coca 4 guest appearances Pat Buttram 3 guest appearances Jack Carson 3 guest appearances Edward Everett Horton 3 guest appearances Jack Benny 3 guest appearances Howard McNear 3 guest appearances Henry Fonda 2 guest appearances Tom D'Andrea 2 guest appearances Jackie Cooper 2 guest appearances Janis Paige 2 guest appearances Carl Reiner 2 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 » ⇥