Recurring Guest Characters B.J. Novak 1 guest appearances Cari Champion 1 guest appearances Mattea Roach 1 guest appearances Amy Schneider 1 guest appearances James Holzhauer 1 guest appearances Mark Duplass 1 guest appearances Emily Hampshire 1 guest appearances Brian Baumgartner 1 guest appearances Timothy Simons 1 guest appearances Christopher Meloni 1 guest appearances Sherri Shepherd 1 guest appearances Shane Battier 1 guest appearances Melissa Fumero 1 guest appearances Adam Rodriguez 1 guest appearances Peter Schrager 1 guest appearances Sheryl Underwood 1 guest appearances Peter Facinelli 1 guest appearances Macaulay Culkin 1 guest appearances Becky Lynch 1 guest appearances Cynthia Nixon 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 » ⇥