Guest Stars Genevieve Kang as Josephine Romaine Waite as Winston Sams Lara Jean Chorostecki as Christina Blake Kimberly J. Brown as Angela Alex Paxton-Beesley as Abby Miller Jason Diaz as Clayton Jeffrey R. Smith as Baxter the Farmer Lindsay Owen Pierre as Emory Nelson Josette Jorge as Librarian Janet Porter as Bethany Bobby Daniels as Minister Richard Ashton as Richards the Diamond Dealer Kyle Buchanan as Lyle Clark Brenda Robins as Mildred Clark Racine Bebamikawe as Bethany's Nurse Carrie Schiffler as Clerk Will Shortz as Police Officer Kintaro Akiyama as Elliot Hannah Kanter as Student Worker Eryk Simon as Angela's Fiance / Groom