Guest Stars Jeremy Fraser as TJ Odette Annable as Catalina Hillary Anne Matthews as Alice Lily Sullivan as Sharon Martha Kelly as Natalie Miles Anderson as St. Peter Kamy D. Bruder as Mateo Stunt Double Sara Sevigny as Woman Johnny Pemberton as Jesus Brooke Coleman as Catalina Stunt Double Brooks Wheelan as Jeffrey Sam Lazarus as Toby Brandon Moten as Puerto Rican Demon #1 Luci Romberg as Natalie Stunt Double Amy Bui as Ruby
