Tell Me Lies - Episode Guide

Lucy starts her freshman year at Baird College, where an unexpected turn of events during Welcome Week flips her life upside down.

Lucy struggles with the aftermath of Welcome Week and goes on her first date with Stephen.

Pressure on Wrigley intensifies, bleeding into his relationship with Pippa. Lucy and Stephen discuss exclusivity.

Bree attempts to lose her virginity. Stephen goes to New York City for the weekend, while Lucy tries to figure out where their relationship stands.

Lucy and Stephen go home for winter break and deal with family tension. Meanwhile, Lucy uncovers a secret. 

Lucy confronts Stephen about what she found at Macy's memorial. 

The group goes to Evan's lake house to celebrate his 21st birthday.

Pippa has complicated feelings after Wrigley meets her dad. Lucy makes a decision to protect Stephen. 

Things between Wrigley and Drew come to a head. Lucy is forced to confront her past.

Lucy and Stephen go to the final party of the semester and everything changes.

Lucy's back at Baird College for sophomore year, ready to start fresh and leave past mistakes behind her.

Bree's birthday takes an unexpected turn. Lucy's excited to focus on someone new.

Stephen baits Lucy as she attempts to rid herself of him once and for all. Wrigley and Pippa finally talk.

As the LSAT looms, Stephen's anxiety grows. Wrigley and Evan have a guy's night out. 

Lydia and Stephen's sister, Sadie, both visit campus for Halloween. Lucy and Pippa learn something unsettling.

When a snowed-in campus forces everyone to Evan's for Thanksgiving, tensions run high.

Lucy and Bree attend a professor's Christmas party. Lucy makes a rash decision that affects Pippa. 

End of semester Christmas celebrations change everything for everyone – again. 

Back at Baird College for spring semester, Lucy and Stephen promise things will be different this time.

Bree encounters an unexpected reunion. Stephen gives Lucy an ultimatum.

The Puswas attend an Apres-Ski frat party. Lucy tries to switch her focus away from Stephen.

A surprising setback sends Diana back into Stephen's orbit. Lucy seeks advice from an unlikely person.

Gossip spirals around Lucy at a pool party. Bree seeks answers from her childhood.

Everyone goes goth for Valentine's Day. Stephen introduces a new friend.

Relationships are tested at Bree's photography exhibition. Lucy devises a plan to finally put rumors to rest.

A scandal erupts at Baird College. When shocking truths come to light, consequences follow for everyone.