Guest Stars A.J. Buckley as Ed Zeddemore Travis Wester as Harry Spengler Shane Meier as Craig Thursten Co Starring Jase Anthony Griffith as Sheriff Agam Darshi as Jill Britt Irvin as First Teenage Girl Krista Bell as Dana Natasha Peck as Second Teenage Girl Nick Harrison as Mordechai Murdoch Gerry MacKay as Mr. Goodwin Jay Nicolas Hackleman as Second Teenage Boy Kyle Labine as Third Teenage Boy Colby Johannson as James