Guest Stars Mary Elizabeth Ellis as Waitress Michael Naughton as Waiter Nick Gehlfuss as Sean Andrew Ridings as Ryan Jareb Dauplaise as Tom Co Starring Gabriela Fresquez as Michelle Aurelia Scheppers as Girl Meredith Giangrande as Nancy Amy Holland Pennell as Vanessa Matthew Jones as Customer #1 Jon Baggio as Toad Man Jenny Phagan as Customer #3 Kimberly Whalen as Kim Jeremy Rabb as Ugly Guy Malea Mitchell as Katie Jayme Lynn Evans as Chrissy Taylor Treadwell as Becky Eric Normington as Customer #2 Pete Carboni as Fred Jen Oda as Nina