Guest Stars Mckenna Grace as Penny Kirkman Reed Diamond as John Forstell Malik Yoba as Jason Atwood Virginia Madsen as Kimble Hookstraten Ashley Zukerman as Peter MacLeish Lara Jean Chorostecki as Beth MacLeish Mariana Klaveno as Brooke Mathison Co Starring Raven Dauda as Yvette Atwood Daren A. Herbert as Alvin Joyner Brendan Beiser as Surgeon Godfrey Giocada as Anesthesiologist Andrea Runge as Captain Betsy Kassabian Calvin Desautels as Agent Damashek Wes Berger as Desk Sergeant Koslowski