Guest Stars Jim Beaver as Bobby Singer Caroline Chikezie as Tamara Peter Macon as Isaac Josh Daugherty as Walter Rosen/Envy Co Starring Ben Cotton as Businessman/Pride Gardiner Millar as Bouncer/Wrath Monique Ganderton as Redhead Katya Virshilas as Pretty Girl/Lust Tiara Sorensen as Waitress / Greed Michael Rogers as Bartender/Gluttony Allison Warnyca as Shoe Shopper C. Ernst Harth as Heavyset Man/Sloth