Guest Stars Jeffrey Dean Morgan as John Winchester Cherilyn Wilson as Lanie Greenfield Tom O'Brien as Clark Adams Anjul Nigam as Stewie Meyers Co Starring Eric Breker as Police Officer Ingrid Torrance as Mrs. Waters Anna Mae Routledge as Museum Tour Guide John Shaw as Mr. Greenfield David Neale as Ben Waters Dawson Dunbar as Simon Greenfield Thomas Michael Dobie as Unknown