Guest Stars Jim Beaver as Bobby Singer Sierra McCormick as Lilith Jack Conley as Sheriff Al Britton Stephan DuVall as John Garland David Mattey as Luther Garland Co Starring Jerry Wasserman as Coroner Michael Roberds as Mark Hutchens Darcy Cadman as Deputy Linus Brady Schlecker as Frank O'Brien Wade Fennig as Frank's Buddy #2 Darren Daurie as Frank's Buddy #1 Jessica Erwin as Unknown