Guest Stars Robert Picardo as Wayne Whittaker Linden Banks as Mr. Brennan Co Starring Mackenzie Porter as Girlfriend Stefan Arngrim as Redcap Trish Allen as Marion Joe Allard as Elf Rob Morton as Sheriff Alisha J. Newton as Little Girl Colin Naples as District Attorney Devon Weigel as Sparrow Jennings Stephen Watts as Elf Rick McLean as Elf Jameson Trenholm as Elf Sienna Bohn as Attractive Waitress Joel Semande as Patrick Brennan