Guest Stars Jim Beaver as Bobby Singer Samantha Smith as Mary Winchester Amber Benson as Lenore Co Starring Julia Maxwell as Eve (The Mother of All) Jason Cermak as Guy in Bar Roman Podhora as Sheriff Valerie McNicol as Dr. Silver's Nurse Chad Rook as Marshall Todd Nathan Witte as Ed Bright Travis Turner as Joe Silver James Upton as Uncle Griffin Parsons as Ryan Silver Ivan Wanis-Ruiz as Jefferson Starship #1 Uncredited Mark Sheppard as Crowley