Guest Stars Alexia Fast as Teenage Emma Harry Groener as Professor Morrison Sara Canning as Lydia Kendall Cross as Charlene Penn Jill Teed as Madeleine Co Starring Lilah Fitzgerald as Preteen Emma Derek Hamilton as First Victim Madison Bell as Young Emma Craig Anderson as Eddie the Coroner Nick Ouellette as Jerry's Neighbor Robyn Thomas as Midwife Kevin Kazakoff as Jerry Price