Guest Stars Matthew Rauch as Clay Burton Geno Segers as Chayton Littlestone Odette Annable as Nola Longshadow Afton Williamson as Alison Medding Harrison Thomas as Jason Hood Tatanka Means as Hoyt Rivers Ólafur Darri Ólafsson as Jonah Lambrecht Amber Midthunder as Lana Cleary Co Starring Deja Dee as Alma Alpha Trivette as Israel Proctor Steve Coulter as Elijah Bowman Jennifer Griffin as Leah Proctor Samantha Worthen as Miriam Bowman Ricky Russert as Tommy Littlestone Gunnar Carrigan as Solomon Bowman Lindsay Ayliffe as Amish Bishop Vivian Fleming-Alvarez as Mercer Prison Guard Marisela Zumbado as June Cleary Abigale Corrigan as Patia Laura Bella as Topless Stripper Angel Tolentino as Lana's Mother Dave Heuvel as Lana's Father Vinston E. Rickman as Kinaho Medicine Man Rain Moore as Paul Moon Mona Amein as Gang Girlfriend Kyle Wolfe as Gang Kid Mike Endoso as Gang Kid #2