Guest Stars Matthew Rauch as Clay Burton Tom Pelphrey as Deputy Kurt Bunker Deja Dee as Alma Alpha Trivette as Israel Proctor Chelsea Cardwell as Beaty Steve Coulter as Elijah Bowman Tanya Clarke as Emily Lotus Chaske Spencer as Deputy Billy Raven Jennifer Griffin as Leah Proctor Samantha Worthen as Miriam Bowman Meaghan Rath as Officer Aimee King Gunnar Carrigan as Solomon Bowman Lindsay Ayliffe as Amish Bishop Chiké Okonkwo as Lennox Carlos Guerrero as Karl 'Yaz' Yazzie Michael Papajohn as Delmont Munson Josh Carter as Smitty Griff Furst as Sheriff Lucas Hood Jerod Meagher as Charlie Knowles Robert John Burke as Commander Salvatore Ferillo Owen Harn as Kendall Josh Henry as a Male Pedestrian Nick Hayner as Turk
