Guest Stars Carlo Marks as David Peck Jessica Sipos as Sarah Mercer Brittany Willacy as Leigh Corley Gregory Harrison as Thomas O'Brien Serge Houde as Del Granger Tom Butler as Lawrence Riley Peter Graham-Gaudreau as Pastor Wade Cameron Bancroft as Carlton Chase Kyle Cassie as Martin Demming Lucie Guest as Kayla Currie Demord Dann as Rob Cooper Allan Gray as Older Actor Susan Evans as Betsy