Guest Stars Rizwan Manji as Tick Pickwick Candis Cayne as The Fairy Queen Esmé Bianco as Eliza Rose Liston as Jane Chatwin Garcelle Beauvais as Persephone / Our Lady Underground Arlen Escarpeta as Prince Ess Dina Meyer as Stone Queen David Lewis as Dr L. Walton Nicholas Coombe as Prince Fomar Co Starring Markian Tarasiuk as Prince Micah Robert Corness as Puzzler Kylee Bush as Arielle Darien Martin as Lunk Latonya Williams as Handmaid Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez as Rupert – Age 5 Tim Donadt as Rupert – Age 20