Guest Stars Adina Porter as Beverly Hope Chaz Bono as Gary K. Longstreet Cooper Dodson as Oz Mayfair-Richards Cameron Cowperthwaite as Speedwagon Co Starring Jess Allen as Sandstorm Johnny Gorman as Heart Attack Kaiwi Lyman-Mersereau as Gutterball Dustin King as Tripod Caleb Foote as Pus Bucket Joseph Will as Councilman Perry Donner-Scott Tisha French as Female Attendant Denver Smith as Male Heaven's Gate Member Martin Mathieu as Councilman Moyer Noelle Messier as Female Heaven's Gate Member Uncredited Evan Peters as Jesus Evan Peters as Jim Jones Evan Peters as David Koresh Evan Peters as Marshall Applewhite