Special Guest Stars Felicia Day as Apocalypse World Charlie Bradbury Guest Stars David Haydn-Jones as Arthur Ketch Richard Speight, Jr. as Trickster / Gabriel Erica Cerra as Dumah Danneel Ackles as Sister Jo / Anael Jeffrey Vincent Parise as Asmodeus Marco Grazzini as Alternate Universe Angel Commander Co Starring Tim Beckmann as Father Davis Curtis Tweedie as Young Priest Corey Schmitt as Bounty Hunter Richard O'Sullivan as Demon Bianca Caroca as Possessed Girl / Anthony
