Guest Stars Anna Hopkins as Lilith Noah Dalton Danby as Russell Raymond Ablack as Raj Javier Muñoz as Lorenzo Rey Co Starring Ariana Williams as Madzie Sophia Walker as Catarina Loss Kevin Alves as Bartholomew 'Bat' Velasquez Brooks Darnell as Charlie Luke Gallo as Rufus Daniel Coz as Disciple #2 Randal Edwards as Tim Neeraja Ramjee as Disciple #1 Michael Giel as Glenn Robyn Alomar as Hostess Doug MacLeod as Mr. Harris Sam Asante as Warlock