Guest Stars Kelly O'Sullivan as Valentina "Voodoo" Dunacci Maura Kidwell as Claire "Stats" Bender Lenny Clarke as Johnny's Dad Jean Smart as Nora Farrell Matt Kozlowski as Stink Hands Matt Lucki as Buddy Brian Doyle-Murray as Monsignor Sullivan Erica Hill as Doctor Brian McCartney as Smolinski Matt Farabee as Zach Gabriel Sullivan as Nate Ana Maria Alvarez as Lady Darielle Deigan as Barista Rosemary