Guest Stars David Sullivan as Chris Barbara Eve Harris as Eileen Curry Emily Yancy as Gayla Beth Broderick as Annie B Catherine Carlen as Deeanna Loretta Fox as Melissa Randy Oglesby as Pastor Jean Villepique as Gretchen Reagan Pasternak as Katie Lacey Lauran September as Angie Ericka Kreutz as Lisa Guy Boyd as Clyde Justin Welborn as Kendall Co Starring Violet Brinson as Kelsey April Brinson as Jodes Sydney Sweeney as Alice Aaron Holliday as Damon London Vanovan as Amanda Nash Ryan James Nelson as Nolan Gracie Prewitt as Tiffanie Nash Gunnar Koehler as Bobby Nash Betsy Baker as Jocelyn Vickery Evan Castelloe as Teen Kirk Lacey Cody Sullivan as Nathan Dylan Schombing as James Capisi Wes Robertson as Jack Olive Ryan as Teen Angie Te'a Jones as Cheerleader #2 Kayla Gonzalez as Cheerleader #4 Sarah Weese as Cheerleader #5 Sam Littlefield as Photographer Zachary Barton as Sarabeth Richard B. Henderson as Rickie Desirae Moya as Little Drummer Girl Kaci Barnes as Cheerleader #7