Guest Stars Jaime Camil voices Don Karnage Kimberly Brooks voices Peg Leg Meg Keith Ferguson voices Ugly Mug David Tennant voices Hat Pirate Danny Pudi voices Pirate 1 Kimberly Brooks voices Hardtack Hattie Kimberly Brooks voices One-Eyed Linda Bobby Moynihan voices Pirate 2 Sam Riegel voices Stinky Boot Sam Riegel voices No-Name The Nameless Parrot Sam Riegel voices Two-Toed Jack Keith Ferguson voices Pirate Intern