Guest Stars Michael Patrick McGill as Tommy Jim Hoffmaster as Kermit Scott Michael Campbell as Brad Kate Miner as Tami Tamietti Jess Gabor as Kelly Keefe Sarah Colonna as Lori Amirah Johnson as Alexandra "Xan" Galvez Eddie Alfano as K.J. Rebecca Field as Eliza Sharif Atkins as Peter Naylor Maddie McCormick as Cory Tamietti Co Starring Melissa Paladino as Cami Claire Donald as Karina Carl W. Crudup as Professor Will Jones as Shirtless Guy Brooke Breit as Paula Jeffrey T. Rogers as Woody Marco Antonio Parra as Nathan