Guest Stars Joe Jones as Felix Manning Matthew McCurdy as Agent Wellers Holly Cinnamon as Julie Angel Rosa as Officer Corbin Scotty Crowe as Agent Lim Abena Mensah-Bonsu as NYPD Officer #2 Bill Buell as Mr. Gerlach Anthony Mecca as Tall Painter Francis Benhamou as Andrea Morales David Walcott as Richie Brett Eidman as Mikey Benjamin Hinnant as Short Painter