Guest Stars Caroline Aaron as Shirley Maisel Brian Tarantina as Jackie Jane Lynch as Sophie Lennon LeRoy McClain as Shy Baldwin Will Brill as Noah Weissman John Scurti as Nicky Zachary Levi as Benjamin Ettenberg Michael Countryman as Simon Lucy DeVito as Irene Joey Slotnick as Dickie Josh Cooke as Mason White John Cariani as Hank Co Starring Nunzio Pascale as Ethan Matteo Pascale as Ethan Matilda Szydagis as Zelda Andrew Polk as Fred Colby Minifie as Ginger Megan McGinnis as Loula Logan Riley Bruner as Lance Karl Miller as Devlin Gary Littman as Kenny Ken Perlstein as Doug Darius de Haas as Shy Baldwin Vocals Connor Russell as Abbie Charissa Hogeland as Florence Laura Sudduth as Cindy Ian Gallagher Fitzgerald as Dancer Nicholas Sipes as Dancer Kaley Ann Voorhees as Lulu Maxwell Zener as Leonard Spencer Clark as Dancer Mary Callahan as Dancer Jordan Betscher as Dancer Corey Snide as Dancer Christina Dooling as Dancer Lauren Sigler as Dancer Andreas Jovovich as Dancer Kristine Zbornik as Judy Kevin Guzewich as Thumb Wrestler #2 Ben Curtis as Waylon Jones Meghan Roberts as B-List Starlet Josh Silverman as Guy in Audience Gadi Rubin as Thumb Wrestler #1 Michael Devine as Sal Scott C. Robertson as Paul Gregg Edelman as Stan Carla Brandberg as Margie Jo Twiss as Woman Uncredited Bob Leszczak as Maisel and Roth Supervisor Bob Lloyd as Marcel Juggler