Guest Stars Jean Smart as Arlane Hart Keiko Agena as Nancy Kevin Zegers as Toby Jake Abel as Trey Lindsey Kraft as Ruth Judy Reyes as Private Investigator Verga Joe Tippett as Bobby Sellars Julie Dretzin as Rebecca Dendrie Taylor as Trailer Park Manager Kiersten Warren as Britt Co Starring Brody Goodstadt as Jonah Sellars Ryder Goodstadt as Jonah Sellars Tiffany Splettstoeszer as Danielle Sitara Hewitt as Casey David Ansell as Pastor Cecilia Hernandez as Female Vocalist #3 John Eli Ibarra II as Male Vocalist #2 Ruby Lopez as Female Vocalist #4 Tristan Rose as Kirby Sellars Destiny Thida Vong as Female Vocalist #2